Thesis
Unpublished
THE CRITICS OF SYED MUHAMMAD NAQUIB ALATTAS TOWARD THE TRANSCENDENTALISM IN RELIGIOUS PLURALISM
Abstract
Transcendentalism is one of the streams of religious pluralism, the pluralists of this school
assume that this understanding is a way out of interfaith meetings because according to them every
religion will meet at an esoteric point, even with different exoteric suggestions. This thought continued
to spread, with one of the initiators being Frithjof Schuon from which it really separated the esoteric
and exoteric dimensions. From there appeared a Muslim thinker named Syed Muhammad Naquib
Al-Attas who dared to criticize that understanding with the perspective of Islam.
Departing from the background above, the researcher wants to discuss the concept of Religion
in the view of Syed Muhammad Naquib Al-Attas which is the basis of criticism of transcendentalism.
The purpose of this study is to understand in depth about the concepts of religion in Islam in the
view of Al-Attas, and to analyze the Schuon version of the transcendentalism concept and western
thinkers, then criticized by Al-Attas so as to get points of weakness in that thought.
This study uses a type of library research and philosophical approach with a combination of
criticism methods to get the results to be achieved, namely dismantling the thoughts of a Muslim
philosopher and thinker named Syed Muhammad Naquib Al-Attas. There are several methods used
in this study. First, the methods of analysis in order to get detailed and comprehensive information
regarding the title of the discussion. Second, the Critical Method to find the weaknesses of the
concept of transcendentalism, using concepts and opinions from Al-Attas and other thinkers in the
same problem variable.
In this discussion, researcher wants to examine the concepts offered by Al-Attas in understanding
and interpreting a “religion” in Islam, namely the term dyn, this conception becomes the basis of a
good understanding of religion in Islam, there are at least four main meanings: (1) Debt situation
or concern, (2) Submission or surrender, (3) Strength of the Law or Judicial Authority, (4) Natural
Will or Natural Tendency. The religious conception of the Al-Attas version is proof of dyn-Islam’s
perfection. Of course, perfect religion has a complete divine and religious foundation and totality in
every aspect. Based on this concept, Al-Attas can criticize the understanding of transcendentalism by
using ontological and psychological views. If transcendence is viewed ontologically, ‘God’ there is
only rabb, not Ilah. Then, if the transcendent is viewed psychologically as ‘the Unity of God’ in the
esoteric dimension, in this condition transcendence is an experience or religious awareness.
Finally, in this study, there are still various shortcomings and imperfections. So, the researcher
hopes that the readers and academics in particular who are involved in the field of study of religions
so that they can further create research with similar themes and be able to cover up any shortcomings
in previous research.
Publication Details
InstitutionUniversitas Darussalam Gontor
DepartmentUSHULUDIN
Item ID2263
Deposited26 Mar 2023 04:21