Journal Article Published

Kritik Orientalis dalam Aspek Ontologis Studi Al-Qur’an

Muttaqin, Muttaqin
Abstract
This article analyzes the Orientalists who study the Qur'an, they are Abraham Geiger,Theodore Noldeke, William Muir, and John Wansbrough. This research uses descriptive analysismethods to find out how Orientalists view and think about the Qur'an. The main data is collectedfrom books related to Orientalist thought as well as from scientific journals. The results foundseveral Orientalist views of the Qur'an in the ontological aspect. Geiger argues that the Qur'an isinfluenced by Judaism which includes: various stories in the Qur’an, morals, and laws, about life,language, and faith. The Prophet Muhammad took a lot of Jewish cultures and integrated theminto Islam. Meanwhile, Noldeke alleged that the Qur'an was composed by the ProphetMuhammad and that many of its contents were plagiarized from the Bible. His criticism of theQur'an can be summarized in two points. First, he stated that the meaning of the ummiy ofRasulullah was not unable to read and write, but the opposite of ahl kitab. Second, according tohim, the Qur'an is not a revelation. Muir attempted to rearrange the chronology of the Qur'anfrom a historical perspective and initiated a chronological theory. Meanwhile, John considers theQur'an not as a holy book but as a collection of notes on the prophetic concepts of the Arabnation and aims to elevate the status of the Arab nation.
Publication Details
JournalAl-Adabiya
Volume17 (2)
Pagespp. 187-200
ISSN1907-1191
KeywordsAbraham Geiger; John Wansbrough; Orientalist; Qur’anic studies; TheodoreNoldeke; William Muir.
Item ID2748
Deposited06 Jun 2023 07:09
Actions
Permalink
Statistics

Statistics Downloads of this Document

Downloads per month in the last year

View more statistics